Disclaimer: This is a work of fiction. I do not know or own Alexa Bliss or Mickie James or Trish Stratus or any other former or current WWE women. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

*

“So Mickie, who do you choose?”

“Huh, what?” Mickie answered softly, her mind still dazed from what she had just been through.

“I asked, who fucked you better, sweetie.” Trish chuckled wickedly.

“Yeah, tell us I’m the best, and then this has-been can bend over like the bitch she is.” Alexa said smugly.

“In your dreams.” Trish scoffed, before pointing out, “I’m Mickie’s first top.”

“So? I’m her current top.” Alexa argued, “If she’s going to pick anyone, it’s going to be me. Her current and best top.”

Mickie James bit her lip, and looked back and forth at her current and former tops, namely Alexa Bliss and Trish Stratus. She truly did adore them both, albeit in very different methods. And choosing between them? That was all the time gonna be an almost impossible task. Almost, but not quite. Because as much as Alexa wouldn’t want to hear it, she just wasn’t as good as Trish. Just didn’t have the same level of experiences her.

It might be a very different story. In a few years, if the current SmackDown women’s champion and Alpha female could hold onto those titles. However, for now, there was a clear winner. It was just Mickie was hesitant to say it, given she knew what the results would be.

Then again, as much as she didn’t want to hurt Alexa, this might actually be good for her. After all, going cold turkey on bottoming could have a negative effect on a female wrestler in the long run. And if Alexa Bliss could survive being topped by the mighty Trish Stratus, then she really would solidify herself as a top. Not as much as if she’d been able to top the mighty Trish Stratus, but it would still be impressive.

And hot. Oh yes, Mickie felt very guilty for it, but the current SmackDown women’s champion and Alpha female had a booty which was made to be fucked. And she wanted to see that, as she wasn’t around for when Alexa was a bottom the first time. Of course, most of all, she was hoping her decision would make Alexa remind her just how good a top she was, with a deep, hard ass pounding.

So after a few long minutes of Alexa and Trish bickering with each other, Mickie spoke up, “I choose Trish.”

There was a brief pause, as both tops turned to the bottom, then Alexa nervously pushed, “To get her big fat ass fucked? Right Mickie?”

“You wish.” Trish scoffed.

“I know!” Alexa insisted, before pushing her favourite bitch, “Tell her!”

“I’m sorry, Alexa.” Mickie said, lowering her head.

“Mickie!” Alexa snapped angrily, before quickly softening her tone, “Just think about this for a second. I’m your top. Your current top, who fills that big fat slutty ass of yours on a daily basis. Do you really want to piss me off? Huh? Because I can definitely make it worth your while, if you make the right choice. If you don’t, what then?”

“She would come home, with me.” Trish offered.

“She doesn’t mean that.” Alexa argued dismissively.

“Yes, I do.” Trish insisted, softly telling her favourite bitch, “I’ve missed you, Mickie. And I totally missed that big fat booty of yours. That’s why I want you to come home with me. Be my permanent bitch.”

“Trish, I…” Mickie began.

“Don’t answer now!” Trish quickly added, “Just promise me you’ll think about it, okay? You know the WWE has never really appreciated you. Not like I do. And let’s face it, if you stay, you would just be used on occasion by lesser tops. I just proved it. But as you, with me, I promise your big fat butt will get all the love it needs at least on a daily basis.”

“She’s just bribing you, Mickie. You know she doesn’t mean it.” Alexa argued, “If she did, she would’ve taken you with her the first time.”

“Actually, that was because she was living her dream, and I didn’t want to take that away from her.” Trish countered, “But now? She’s lived it. And despite being one of the biggest bottoms ever, has achieved everything she possibly can. But that was up against inferior competition. And, I’m sorry Mickie, in this generation? You just can’t compete. And you know it.”

“Are you hearing this? Is this who you’re going to let top us? Top me?” Alexa complained, “A weak top, who doesn’t even believe in you?”

“Do you really think you can be champion?” Trish questioned.

“With me by her side? Maybe.” Alexa lied, before quickly adding, “Or at least, it’s like she’s champion with me. And maybe they’ll introduce some women’s tag team titles?”

“Yeah, because tag teams in this company get the respect they deserve.” Trish grumbled.

“The same could be said about the women, only a few years ago.” Alexa quipped, before pointing out, “But, that’s not the point. The point is, Mickie is better off with me. You have to know that, don’t you?”

There was a telling pause, then Mickie softly said, “I’m sorry, Alexa. My mind is made up.”

“But-” Alexa began, only to be quickly interrupted.

“No more buts. Except of course, yours. Ha ha ha ha, ooooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhh! And, this!” Trish taunted, bending over, and wiggling her big booty, “Ohhhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssss, take a good look, Alexa! Mmmmmmmmm fuck yeah, take a good look at the booty you won’t be fucking. Yeahhhhhhhhhhhh, take a really good look. And by that, I mean kiss it. Yessssssssssssss, mmmmmmmmmmm, kiss my ass, bitch. Become my ass kissing little bitch. Just like Mickie James will always be. Ooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssssss, pucker up! Become what you were always meant to be, my ass kisser! Ha ha ha ha, oooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssssss!”

While Trish continued taunting the other blonde, Alexa gave Mickie a pleading look, which then probably turned to annoyance as the brunette looked away. Because instantly, she questioned her own decision, although Mickie knew that would be the case, regardless of her choice. And more importantly, she couldn’t just change her mind now.

No, they would be here all night, with the two blondes arguing about the decision. Yes, it was much better to just accept that Trish had won, and try and move forward from there. Also, just enjoy the show. Or at least, as much as she could. Mostly because the greedy little bottom craved being part of the action, and hoped she would return to it soon.

She definitely wished she was right beside Alexa, kissing Trish’s amazing ass. Oh yes, Mickie had to avoid biting her lip to avoid begging for that very thing, as she was sure that Trish just wanted to savour her victory right now. Besides, she was trained better than that. So she was a good girl, and just watched for the next few long minutes, which felt like an eternity.

Which to be fair, did a great job revitalizing her. Especially as she had been in that position many times, kneeling behind that big glorious booty, and eagerly worshiping it. Hell, she’d even been in Trish’s position, as the likes of both Trish and Alexa loved playing with her fat butt in a variety of different methods.

Alexa was furious it had come to this, and would be definitely punishing Mickie for making the wrong decision at the next available opportunity. Just like she promised she would make sure that whatever she received tonight, Trish would take tenfold when she finally got the better of her. However, she couldn’t expect Trish to honour her word, if she broke hers now.

So, while she may not like it, Alexa had to do whatever this bitch said for the rest of the night. And honestly, of all the things she could make her do, this was quite an easy and even tame starting point. One which gave The Goddess the chance to imagine that she had been given the victory she had earned, and was now having fun with her prize.

Because while it was arguably not a top thing to do, Alexa definitely enjoyed sliding her lips over a pair of meaty cheeks, and this was definitely no exception. Hell, she had dreamed of doing this so many times before. Admittedly, it was followed by her topping the mighty Trish Stratus.

But not all the time. Oh God, to her great shame, even though she’d made great progress lately to become a top, a big part of her was still Little Lexi The Butt Slut. And Trish Stratus just had such a wonderfully big booty, it was hard for Alexa not to imagine herself dropping down to her knees, and worshiping it with her lips. Among so many other things she really wanted to do to the other blonde, and was now pretty much guaranteed to receive.

For better or for worse, she could forget about those other things, at least for a while, and drowned out the other blonde’s encouragement, as she simply concentrated on literally being an ass kisser. Which involved starting with one long, lingering kiss to Trish’s left butt cheek, before moving over to the right to give it the same treatment.

She then went back and forth, making sure that her lips covered every inch of those meaty cheeks, before inevitably going after her real target. The one she had convinced herself would be hers by the end of the night. Maybe even permanently. Oh yes, she spread those big fat butt cheeks with both hands, and took a few long seconds just to admire the other woman’s back door.

Once again, she promised herself that it would be hers. That one night in the future, Trish Stratus would be her little lezzie bitch. Then she spat onto that back door, and then rubbed that saliva in with her tongue. Over and over again Alexa repeated the process, before settling into a nice long rim job.

Which finally had the other blonde forgetting her taunting words, in favour of letting out long moans, cries and whimpers of pleasure. Just like she would do, when Alexa was preparing the mighty Trish Stratus for a butt fucking. Something which again, was easy to imagine given the circumstances. Even if the real situation was never far from her mind, or the mind of the other blonde.

Trish hadn’t really intended to get this far. Having a defeated opponent literally have to become her ass kisser was a wonderful humiliation for her latest conquest, and had Trish feeling very proud of herself. However, more often than not, without her permission, that opponent would begin eating her ass, just like this.

Something which was well within the multi-time champion’s power to stop anytime she wanted. But the issue was, she didn’t want to stop it. No, it felt good. So very, very good. Fuck, it was so good, some women had even turn the tables on her, turning her from the conqueror into the conquered. But for better or for worse, she was as sure as she could be that that wasn’t the case with this pathetic little wannabe.

Sure enough, Alexa seemed to get lost in kissing her ass, and then eating it. Just like most of her previous bitches, which was why Trish all the time took this risk. Well, the main reason. And it was also why she pretty much all the time allowed this to go on longer than necessary. Even to the point where a tongue was being pushed into her butt hole.

Even when it slid all the way inside what was supposed to be a forbidden hole. Oh God, that was a delicious reminder of how despite all her success, both in and out of the ring, Trish Stratus had been anally defiled countless times, causing what was supposed to be her most private hole to be forever loose. Loose enough to take an entire tongue, no issue.

Worried that she was about to begin begging for a toy in there, and maybe even Alexa’s strap-on, Trish cried out, “That’s enough of that. Ooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhhh, bend over, bitch! Give me your ass! Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssssss, mmmmmmmmmm, it’s high time that, Little Lexi The Butt Slut got the attention she craves 24/7.”

Reluctantly pulling her tongue from that tasty treat, Alexa asked hopefully, “Are you sure you wouldn’t rather be taking my cock?”

There was a telling pause, and then Trish just laughed, “Nice try, but have to do better than that. Mmmmmmmmm, yeah you will. So do as I say. And answer properly.”

Another brief pause, and then Alexa grumbled, “Yes, Mistress.”

“Good girl.” Trish chuckled, “Mmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhh, good little butt slut. In fact, I think you’ve been so good, I’m going to give you a reward.”

“The chance to fuck your fat ass?” Alexa quipped, before crying out joyfully as Trish buried her face in between her ass cheeks, and went to work on her back door, “Ah fuck! Oooooooooooh fuck yeah, eat me! Eat my ass, you nasty bitch. It’s only fair. Yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh, it’s only fair that you would get to tongue my beautiful butt hole, given how much time I wasted licking your whore hole. The whore hole you call an ass hole, which is clearly been fucked like a million times, mmmmmmmmm, by every girl to lace up a pair of boots. Ohhhhhhhhhh yessssssssssss, rim me, rim me good! Oooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeessssssssssssss, eat that ass, and-“

“Get it ready for my cock?” Trish quipped back with an evil grin.

Of course, Trish would love to have said more, but not as much as she wanted to continue eating that hot little booty. In fact, she went right back to it, and probably wouldn’t have pulled her face out of it, even if Alexa had gone back to the taunting. Hell, maybe Alexa did go back to the taunting, and Trish was just so preoccupied with the rim job that she didn’t notice.

If that was the case, she had no regrets, as this was truly a tasty hole. One of the new ones available, which she was well within her rights to savour. Especially as there was no guarantee that she would get it again. No, she fully intended to take her time with every part of this, which to be fair, was doing a wonderful job of teasing her pray.

Which was clear with every whimper, whine and moan that the other blonde let out. Which in turn, as all the time, was the sweetest music to Trish’s ears. Okay, maybe not, as this wasn’t Mickie, but it was still pretty sweet. Especially when she inevitably picked up the pace of the rimming.

Because while on the one hand, part of her would’ve been happy to eat that big ass all night long, she was also craving the part when she would move on to giving this slutty little bitch hole the pounding it deserved. So inevitably, she swirled her tongue around what was supposed be a forbidden hole, and even pushing it inside. Something which was super easy for her, and caused Trish to chuckle wickedly. Meanwhile, it got the same sort of reaction from poor Little Lexi The Butt Slut.

Alexa tried to remain focused on the idea that she was in control, just so that she could put off surrendering to her submissive side for a little bit longer. Ideally, all night long, as she really, really didn’t want to give Trish that satisfaction. However, while she was hesitant to admit it, even to herself, Alexa knew that just wasn’t feasible. That her bubble butt was just too slutty.

So slutty, that even when Mickie rimmed her, it made her want a cock inside her ass. And this wasn’t just some bottom, but a former Alpha female, who knew just how to tease even the most reluctant of back doors to the point that they would accept a cock. And again, it really didn’t take that much with her slutty little butt hole.

Hell, even before she started receiving a rim job, Alexa was hot and horny for everything that happened with Mickie, and the rim job she had given to Trish. So much so, that if she had just been made to bend over, Alexa’s whore ass could have taken the full length of Trish’s now re-attached strap-on, with just a little bit of lube. Like what Mickie was now rubbing into it.

But for better or worse, she found herself whimpering, moaning and crying out joyfully as she received one of the best butt munchings of her life. Oh God, that tongue was just too talented, showing her slutty little back door absolutely no mercy. Especially when it came to fucking it. When the other top would push that tongue as deep as it would go into her bottom, and then thrust the full length in and out for what felt like an eternity.

“Spread your cheeks!” Trish then abruptly ordered, smacking that fat booty to emphasize her words.

“Ah fuck! Mmmmmmmm, yes Mistress Trish.” Alexa moaned dreamily, and did as she was told without hesitation, even slowly spreading those cheeks, just as she had been trained.

She was just too lost in the wonderful rim job, that she was taken by surprise when Trish replaced her tongue with her cock. Naturally, Alexa had been expecting fingers next. Not that she needed them, but they would’ve been a nice escalation, to ease her into the butt sex. Instead, the head of that cock effortlessly slid through her now forever loose back door, and into her bowels.

Something that Trish seemingly savoured for a few long seconds, probably with an infuriatingly smug smile on her face. Then she began pushing forwards, finding it just as easy to push the full length of her strap-on cock into the other woman’s shit-pipe. And honestly, it could have been probably done a lot faster, but for better or for worse, the multiple times former Alpha and champion insisted on going slow.

Obviously, this was a good thing, because it minimized the pain that Alexa felt. However, pain would be preferable, to her constant cries of pure pleasure, just from getting her ass stuffed with a strap-on dildo. Something which would have been incredibly painful for most people, but to a female wrestler in the WWE?

For most of them, it was as natural as breathing. And Alexa arguably had it worse than most. She’d only just begun to turn around her fortunes, becoming the SmackDown women’s champion, and topping worthless butt sluts, like Becky Lynch and Naomi. And of course, her precious Mickie James. But she was arguably the most trendy anal whore in NXT, and at the Royal Rumble, she had been reminded by Charlotte Flair just how much fun it could be to get fucked in the ass.

Trish had fucked the sluttyest butt holes imaginable. The ones belonging to truly legendary ass whores, like Stacy Keibler, Torrie Wilson and maybe especially Mickie James. And this ass was easily on that level. Hell, it might have been even better, given just how much Alexa seemed to be enjoying this, despite the fact that she literally been on a winning streak, and therefore only topping, since leaving NXT.

Which now was obviously being exposed as a lie. Because sure, Alexa might’ve been winning a lot lately, but she was totally sneaking off to get her ass fucked on the daily. Either that, or she was just that big of a butt slut in NXT. Or she was just such a natural anal whore, that she was literally made for this company.

It was probably a combination of all three, but most of all, the last one. Oh yes, just one look at that big bubble butt of hers, and it was clear that Alexa Bliss had been made to be in the WWE, bending over for superior women, left right and centre. Something which Trish fully intended to make clear to this natural butt whore. Well, even more clear than it was already. At least, whenever she got her voice back.

Because for what felt like an eternity, she was lost in the gorgeous sights and sounds she got from that big dick effortlessly being stuffed into that whore hole. Of course, inevitably her thighs came to rest against those meaty cheeks, announcing every inch of her big dick was buried within Alexa’s shit-pipe. Which of course, Trish just had to gloat about.

“Oh fuck, every inch!” Trish moaned dreamily, then grinned wickedly, finding her voice had finally returned, which she used to her full benefit, “That’s every single inch of Trish Stratus’s big dick in Alexa Bliss’s cute little bubble butt! Ooooooooooooh yeah, it is. And you know what that means, don’t you Lexi? Yeah you do, because you’ve done this a thousand times. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh yessssssssss, Paige, Becky, Sasha… Charlotte? They’ve all had this ass. Mmmmmmmm fuck, I bet even Bayley and Mickie have had a turn with it. And now it’s me, balls deep in the frequently used fuck hole you call an ass hole. Ha, and you thought you can compared to me. Yeahhhhhhhhh, ha ha ha ha, isn’t that funny, Mickie?”