Allison had caught me cheating on her with Stephanie again. It took a while but she finally agreed to come to my condo so I could apologize and try to convince her to stay with me.

As we were making up, she confessed that thinking about me being sexual with Stephanie was making her horny. She wanted me to show her what we did.

I was shocked. The idea of acting out my infidelity with her and showing her how I cheated on her was turning me on as well.

I told her to walk to the kitchen. As she got there I grabbed her hips from behind and pulled her to me, whispering in her ear, “As soon as I walked in to her house, I grabbed Stephanie just like this and whispered into her ear, ‘I want you Steph, I want you right now.’”

I kissed Allison’s neck as I pulled her top up over her breasts, cupping them and lightly rubbing her nipples between my fingers.

“Mmm this made her nipples hard too”, I said softly as she turned her head and we kissed passionately.

“Do you want me to keep going?” I asked her.

“Mmm hmm,” was all she could say as I continued playing with her breasts.

I turned Allison around to face me and leaned her against the counter, stripping her top off over her head.

I kissed her lips and then slowly kissed down to her breasts. I sucked on one nipple and then the other, squeezing her boobs as I looked up at her, “Mmm I sucked on Stephanie’s tiny tits just like this, Al.”

I kissed down Allison’s tummy as I got on my knees in front of her. I undid her jeans and slid them down to the floor. I kissed her mound through the thin fabric of her already very wet panties.

I slowly pulled her panties to the floor, kissing her upper thighs and the mound of her bare pussy, teasing her.

Looking up at Allison from my knees I told her, “I couldn’t wait to taste her pussy, Al.”

I kissed Allison’s pussy lips, I licked them and I sucked on them. “Mmm her pussy was so wet, Al. It tastes so good.”

Allison grabbed the back of my head and pressed it to her, moaning as I licked her clit.

I lifted her onto the counter. She laid back and I licked and sucked and fingered her incredible pussy. She wrapped her thighs tight around my head.

“Did she suck your cock?” Allison asked through her moans.

“She pushed me against the wall and got down on her knees,” I told her.

Allison slid off the counter and did the same, pushing me backwards. She got down on her knees, undid my belt, and pulled my rock hard cock out.

She rubbed the head of my cock over her nipples. “Did Stephanie do this for you, too?” She asked.

“No. I love it when you rub it on your boobs, Al. That feels sooo good.” It drove me wild when Allison did that to my cock.

Allison wrapped her lips around my cock and slowly sucked up and down. She took my hands and put them on either side of her head.

“Show me how she sucked you,” she said looking into my eyes as she put my cock my cock back in her mouth.

I guided her head up and down my cock just like Stephanie would do. She was looking me in the eyes the whole time.

“Mmm flick the tip with your tongue”, I told her. “Just like that. Mmm that’s just how Stephanie does it.” It was incredible.

Allison slid her lips from my cock and began rubbing it on her tits again.

“Do you want to see how I fucked her?” I asked.

Still looking up at me from her knees, she nodded, biting her lip.

I pulled Allison to her feet, wrapped my arms around her and kissed her deeply. I took her by the hand to the sofa in the living room and bent her over the end of it.

I spread her legs and rubbed the head of my cock along her pussy lips. “This drove her wild,” I said.

“Mmm fuck me. Make me your slut too,”Allison moaned.

I pushed my cock deep inside her pussy.

“She was so tight, Al.” I said, my hands pulling her hips tight against me.

My thrusts grew faster and harder. Allison’s moans grew louder.

She turned her head looking back at me, “Tell me how much you liked fucking her slutty pussy.”

“Her pussy felt soooo good. It was so tight and she moaned so loud.”

“Mmm your cheating cock feels soooo good!” She moaned.

Fucking Allison like this felt so amazing. This was so hot. I wanted to show her every way we fucked.

“Ride me, Al. I want you to ride me on the sofa like she did.”

I sat down on the sofa and pulled Allison on top of me.

She held the base of my cock and her very wet pussy slid easily down my shaft. Her tits started bouncing perfectly for me.

“I bet her tiny boobs don’t bounce like mine do,” Allison said with a sly grin.

Allison was so hot riding me. Moaning loudly. Squeezing her tits for me.

I pulled her to me and told her to begin grinding and rocking back and forth on my cock while I sucked her cute tits.

“Is this what you want?” She asked. “Is this what your slut did for you?”

“Mmm hmm,” was all I could say.

Allison felt so fucking good.

“Do you like sucking her tits or mine better?” She asked.

“Mmm your perky tits, Al. I love sucking your tits,” I replied.

I lifted Allison off my cock, spun her around and placed her down on the sofa on her back. Positioning myself on the floor in front of her, I placed her legs on either of my shoulders and pressed my cock inside her, grabbing her by the hips.

“Stephanie liked to rub her clit while I fucked her,” I told Allison and she immediately went with it.

I fucked her as she rubbed her clit. We were both talking dirty about cheating.

“Do you like having her as your slutty fuck toy? Is this making you want to fuck her again?” She asked.

“Oh fuck, yes I want to fuck her again. I want to feel her pussy again. I want to suck on her tiny tits again.” I confessed.

She was rubbing her pussy, moaning so loudly as I fucked her harder.

“Did you cum in her pussy?”

“Yes, it felt sooo good!” I replied.

That sent Allison over the edge. Her body began shaking and her pussy tightened around my cock as the orgasm washed over her.

“Cum in my pussy!” Allison screamed.

That made me cum instantly.

“I’m cumming!” I yelled out in pleasure as I pumped her pussy hard. We passionately kissed as our orgasms began to subside.

I laid beside Allison and kissed her boobs while my fingers traced over her pussy lips.

She didn’t say anything for a while. Tears welled up in her eyes. I asked if she was ok with what just happened.

She said, “Yes, I’m just processing it all.”

After a little bit, she kissed me and looked me in the eyes. “Now I have a confession to make,” she said with a smile.

To be continued…

This is my first draft of this story. Please opinion with any ideas/suggestions to improve it. Thanks for reading!

NSFW: yes